Tuesday 17 February 2015

Morning Mumble: Greek Poker Clap-O-Meter, New Palm Oil or Napalm for Noble...???

Good Morning, 

Long day yesterday, on the way home I was reminded of my views just after the Greek election. Its felt Greece have a greater agenda than the debt and appear to be acting like they have nothing to lose. The poker face has big stakes (€323 billion), in the immediate if the grand total is excluded, this year alone Greece is meant to repay €26b. The Greek government are in a better position than those that are owed the money. Greece although failing in their international obligations, can enforce the hair cut with a sense of popularity. 

Excluding the IMF, International Bailout Fund and the combined total of "other European bonds", Germany, France, Italy and Spain all have the most to lose if Greece default. Well that's what analysts hope Italy and Spain don't notice, as its actually only Germany and France. There would be no reason for Italy or Spain to continue the status quo in the event of Greek default. 

Just after the election, I was in a meeting not with Greeks, but with two of the five living in Greece and they're of the view it's about as close as Scotland going independent*. That's fairly close for any analyst, logically if the populous are blaming the conditions for the bailout on the issues, then one is going to gain popularity whilst being in poverty, unity so to speak.

Greece is 50/50 on leaving the Euro, perhaps not the Euro-currency until such time as the Greek Government can appoint De La Rue for a little paper to be able to print the Drachma notes. The Greek Government allegedly created the note designs in 2012 when the EU hypothesised about the Grexit plan. 

If you've got tough measures to swallow, you may as well go it cold turkey and be done with it. Often when there's little left, it’s perhaps the wisest of options, reset of Greek economy and expectations. Consider the Grexit a resetting of standards, with significant consequences both locally and internationally, expect stocks to act accordingly with a sense of risk.

Off to the market, with Brent being the new copper (*currently keeping its head above $2.60/lb). The global bellwether of indicators, bouncing near 25% from lows, with supplies of WTI being greater than Brent, its premium to WTI is going to be validated in the short-term. It’s a hard call with Brent, with Greece wobbling, and the market pricing in rig reductions in advance, there's a good possibility (65%) of $70/bbl Brent and $64-68/bbl for WTI, save for a melt-down or two. A lifeline to those marginal oil producers and even Afren might have a new opportunity, but one doesn't hold out much hope. 

The latest victim of analysis appears to be Noble Group with the most publicised version being Iceberg Research. Having not read most of the report save for the headlines, people would be wise to see how this unfolds. Noble Group manages a portfolio of global supply chains covering a range of agricultural and energy products, as well as metals, minerals and ores. Quite why Iceberg Research published a report if they don't trade in the Singapore market and hasn't participated in any trade related to Noble Group. Unless something bigger is coming along... ...

Staying with Noble's theme, Simbe Darby Plantation may have just had a well-timed takeover of New Britain Palm Oil (NBPO). The palm oil market certainly looks to be turning a corner bouncing away from a critical $601/t. There's risks to the supply chain as Eltinus Omaleng, the bupati of Mimika Regency in Papua, has officially issued a decision document to call a complete stop to PT Pusaka Agro Lestari (PAL)’s activities. 

PAL is operated by Noble Group on behalf of COFCO, (China National Cereals, Oils and Foodstuffs Corporation). Whether legal or not it may go some-way to support the price as the industry signs to longer-ended-dated contracts that will change the sentiment in palm oil prices. In the event the excessive supplies continue to come to market palm oil is heading to $427-433/t. Those lipstick wearers can relax, supplies aren't that bad they need to start hoarding their favourite reds! 

A poignant day at Shaft Sinkers, bringing together those holders around an oil barrel to torch their certs. Shaft Sinkers suspends their stock with, "no value remaining that is attributable to the equity in the Company." This company is worth significant analysis, especially for a certain brokerage that published a report in 2011 that brought Shaft Sinkers to my attention. How SHFT managed 4 years 2 months on the market is a feat in itself, a bull market play that in a cash conscious environment was doomed to failure and will never succeed where the risks are not equitable with the owners of miners. 

Kenmare Resources (KMR) come out and state they've laid off 14% of their staff it was too little, too late to stave off the impact of reduced prices. There's going to be a further 15-20% of redundancies in the future. These actions appear to suggest that Iluka Resources whom can see potential if the employees are halved. With respect to some, it was not hard to work out if you're carrying an inventory of circa 25% of your annual sales that you can reduce costs by near 25%. Perhaps time to save a little in board room pay as well? Over to Iluka! 

EMC: As a seller of GEM Diamonds, validated the view on Gemfields (GEM) with their market update as Q4 trading was under pressure. Production up, costs up and grades down plus Faberge being impacted by Russian spending down a not so insignificant 12%. The diamond and precious gem sector is the Christmas trading quarter with restocking and reading across the numbers, the market doesn't appear to be in sparkling health! (I known).

The Russian's woes won't be the only issue as investors consider a conservative approach to investing and extravagance. Over to Ian Harebottle, CEO of GEM whom "remain upbeat about the growth and development of our sector and look forward to the results of our two forthcoming auctions and the various luxury events scheduled to take place over the next few months." 

It would be wise to believe there's still a softening in the market (not forever) and GEM have a lower quality rough emerald and beryl auction scheduled for the end of the month. If the gossip of a share consolidation is correct for GEM, they'd be wise to wait until the market has more clarity, what more does one need than a greater downside than up! 

Quadrise Fuels International (QFI) holders appear to be badgering the company why the price has tanked so much. The sell was July 2014 (EMC QFI July 2014), not with hindsight but more clarity required on the potential of QFI. Those whom appear shocked by the company's tank even after the Business Update. Do the holders have any understanding of the concept of the model, that being the difference between heavy fuel oil and diesels. Stick with utilities if in doubt...

Congratulations to Aureus Mining Inc. (AUE), who got the ink dry on the equity financing they announced recently including the rump from the IFC (International Finance Corporation). Save for further Ebola issues and further delays, AUE could just be on the turn. The New Liberty mine even allowing for higher all in cash costs by my figures of  $937/oz., still has a decent margin of profit not at today's prices, and would make circa IRR 25% at $1171/oz. 

Wood Group (WG.) reminding the market its not all doom and gloom, with full year results for the year ended 31 Dec 2014, but perhaps not out of the woods yet! 

Atb Fraser

*Political Rant: Well ignore the fact that Alex Salmond was categorically wrong, just look at the bellwether of oil that he relied so heavily upon. In supporting him, had your desired outcome occurred you'd have been selling the big issue to the English Government again, rather than the UK Government when needing a little assistance?

3 comments:

  1. Fraser- Hi- some interesting RNSs today, with blue appearing after the early Grexit falls overnight from the eastern markets. I cant see an option that see Greece stay in the Euro and they appear to be ignoring my Ruble suggestions, which would please any Russian investors still stuck in Cyprus... hey ho :-))

    Re QFI- the halving of the oil prices will probably have halved the gap between heavy fuel oil and diesel prices by default, so whilst the gap is still there, the numbers all drop in tandem. The main issue with MSAR is that the global players (Maersk, the Saudi refineries, Ecopetrol) have v long winded pipelines of projects and delays are all a part of the process- the oil drop will have tightened budgets and moved quite a bit of capex back, so the mkt needed to adjust to the new reality re $60 oil rather than $100 oil. I can still see the marine project moving ahead in 2015 but they need to sign up a major refinery or two first. So more delays but the tech works so patience and adding/selling at the right times is key for me here- QFI is clearly my most traded stock, and v profitable too. Long only just does work with QFI.

    Re GEM- Not sure if a consolidation would be of any real benefit here- the shares don't trade at 0.05p and 50p or so is a reasonable price so why waste time and money with a 1 for 10... plus I cant think of one that has enhanced value, they seem to be done when a share price has dropped off the radar, which isn't the case with GEM. Im happy to hold GEM in the long/forever category as their 75% ownership model clearly works and they have rubies flying now, plus sapphires coming soon. The auction process clearly adds value and has transformed the coloured gemstones market so well done to GEM from me.

    Cheers. The Leggie

    ReplyDelete
  2. Greece is really interesting. I suspect the issue may be more mundane and boring than most commentators are thinking - I think it is a failure of a relatively naïve and new government in Athens to understand how to deliver what it wants and needs in a bureaucratic situation.

    The Eurocrats have tried to explain to Greece that any bailout (or technically an extension of the current bailout to Sept) requires ratification by the national parliaments in the Eurozone.

    The Greek position is no bailout and lets negotiate new terms. The reason for the crisis is that the Greeks are missing the point that any negotiation of new terms is not going to happen overnight, requires buy-in from democratically elected governments in multiple countries and will take time. Even if new terms were agreed today it is likely it would take more than 2 weeks for national EZ parliaments to ratify them.

    Hence the most logical plan for the Greeks is to extent the current bailout to Sept, to give themselves (and everyone else) some breathing space and use that to explain and win the confidence of national parliaments elsewhere in Europe to new terms. However the current Greek govt. appears to be politically naïve.

    Frankly what they are saying is 'lend us new money, but on our terms and without any verification'. It may sound rude to say this, but it is rather 'Southern European' in its approach.

    Bizarrely many of the points that the new Greek govt. are making are actually sensible but they are losing the argument due to their positioning.

    So how ought this to end:
    (1) Greece applies for an extension of the current bailout over the forthcoming weekend in order to buy time to negotiate a new structure by Sept
    (2) Brussels / the EU / OECD and perhaps even the IMF / WB / Japan and the US offer a support package of Euro 5 - 10 billion to alleviate the worst social issues with immediate effect.

    Between now and Sept the new Greek govt agree to the outstanding offer from Germany of 200 tax inspectors and training on tax collection. (Germany offered this about 3 - 4 years ago and it was turned down by the previous govts - can't imagine why).

    Secondly the Greeks are seconded a group of economists from the UK / US and elsewhere to help remodel / rebuild their economy.

    Thirdly north European EU countries agree tax incentives for their companies on profits derived from manufacturing in Greece.

    Fourthly Tsipras goes on a tour of China and studies Marxist economics. Not allowed back until he understand Deng's phrase 'It does not matter if the cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice.'


    Will any of the above occur - unlikely.

    I think Greek is about to 'accidentally' exit the Eurozone. The consequences will be awful. The population (at least the middle classes and above) will not abandon the Euro. The poor will be forced to hold drachma. There will be two inflation rates in the economy - dependent on whether you earn drachma or euros....etc
    Roddy

    ReplyDelete
  3. Roddy I agree to a degree (not that it matters). Does the Greek population understand what their Government is doing? Whether they understand or not there's a certain agenda I noticed from his (Alexis Tsipras) first words. The actions may become the Greek solidarity for 10+ years to come. Something I suspect Germany is more anxious about than anyone if you appraise their current account deficit compared to wider Europe.

    TC F

    ReplyDelete