Thursday 24 December 2015

Morning Mumble: What a year! How do you spell Christmas?

Good Morning,

It's been a pleasure and thank you for the many words/thoughts. 

We shall endeavour to post some musings over the Christmas break, what with various items taking priority EMC has taken a back seat. We had our first 'proper' scoop in the western hemisphere the other day, a pleasure and 24hrs before the rest!

The lack of reporting on the "convention" of base metal traders meeting this weekend to discuss...purchasing more metals. One might also need to consider that some out of the money traders will look to take the losses, but at least some Christmas cheers for those long. Expect some adjustments in stockpiling and the reporting of such numbers. (EMC: China Base Metals)

Here's hoping everyone enjoys the festive break and gets some 'R&R.' Li is heading to Macau this year, obviously gambling and the like; who'd have thought it!?! We should feel privileged some declined such opportunity in Macau and are UK bound. No doubt laden with anything duty free like thinking they've got a 'real bargain.'

Yesterday was a proverbial bath with Oxus's failure in their arbitration outcome. The mystery is how Richard Shead kept the RNS professional in light of what some consider a failing in a legal process. 

There will be Oxus update in the new year, but don't expect too much. The monies awarded should cover Calunius's costs, albeit little left over. One would be very surprised if there was an appeal save of course for a curve ball of showing complete incompetence by one of the panel. Is that possible? 

This was not a case of quantum but of reliability of the facts...something that an entity may be able to argue quite cleanly. Fit for practice springs to mind....albeit taking no shine off a stellar year as prudence always suggests taking profits along the way, the beauty of these types of arb type cases. 


We shall await the "trading updates in January!" One cannot help but wonder what the level of inventory in the shops implies for their bottom line. We note the contributors to EMC retail opportunistic survey finding healthy levels in most stores with very few non-food items being sold out (The largest number of contributors we've had - thank you!). 


Does Christmas now start with an E(commerce)?

All the best and Merry Christmas, Fraser

Tuesday 22 December 2015

Morning Mumble: Concha & some base metals + Glencore's Chinese Zinc Premium

Good Morning,

After abuse for over a year relating to Concha, its a poignant time to remind parties of: EMC: Concha - CHA Cha cha (No known links to Cuba) & congratulation to non-holders of CHA & Kefi. The market is finally pricing things in? It's about the money for now...but one to run away from.

The lack of reporting on the "convention" of base metal traders meeting this weekend to discuss...purchasing more metals. One might also need to consider that some out of the money traders will look to take the losses, but at least some Christmas cheers for those long. Expect some adjustments in stockpiling and the reporting of such numbers.

Glencore (GLEN) may not have to update the market on their Zinc pricing but it has not gone unoticed they've reduced their Chinese premium considerably, albeit tightened the band, it's still down. Previously $160-130/t to $125-110/t. Strangely in line with Korea and Hindustan producers.

Atb Fraser

Monday 21 December 2015

Morning Mumble: Should we set up a due diligence Firm of Randgold? + Plus Other News..

Good Morning,

What does it say for the risks of management when companies are prepared to consider joint ventures on assets that are uneconomic? Of course regular readers will remember the EMC: Volte Face Randgold Resources from September... after: EMC: Randgold preferred Fed Arb play. 

To quote:

Whether its Elephant country or not (FT), prudence dictates purchasing a decent asset with a better outlook than Obuasi. Good money after...As a reminder, PWC's Mining Taxes and Royalties (PDF)s  and an article (Ghana Chamber of Mines) that AngloGold Ashanti's might want one to quickly forget.  

Disappointing waste of time on RRS and perhaps losing ones mind! When investors thousands of miles away from the mine can assess the benefits or lack of in investing in Ghana, concerns should prudently be raised. More later...

It would appear Randgold needed to spend significant time and perhaps money conducting due diligence to form the same opinion as EMC. Today, they give an update on the Obuasi Gold Mine. Over to Randgold (Bold Italics and Underline are additions):

Jersey, Channel Islands, 21 December 2015

On 16 September 2015, Randgold Resources Limited (Randgold) and AngloGold Ashanti Limited (AngloGold Ashanti) announced their intention to form a joint venture to redevelop AngloGold Ashanti's Obuasi mine in Ghana, subject among other things to the completion of satisfactory due diligence by Randgold and the agreement of a revised development plan.  After undertaking a due diligence exercise into the mine and the redevelopment opportunity the mine affords, and following the work undertaken on the revised development plan, Randgold has determined that the development plan will not satisfy Randgold's internal investment requirements.  Accordingly, Randgold has decided to terminate the investment agreement entered into with AngloGold Ashanti, with immediate effect.

Chief Executive Mark Bristow said Randgold remained committed to creating real value for all its stakeholders by continuing to invest substantially in its exploration programmes with their proven record of success as well as by investigating potential growth opportunities presented by the market.

What due diligence was needed to formulate the same view as here?? Randgold can now throw in the towel and purchase Amara Mining’s (AMA), Yaoure Project, whom recently gave an update on grade and resource.  

In other news, the AIM loses a director whom had sat on a few boards…one such company, BacanoraMinerals Ltd. Perhaps entities were finding their proverbial taps cut off…same for AfriAgPLC, InspiritEnergy (INSP), EvocutisPlc and RareEarth Minerals. Apologies if they weren't all covered…

We have not ignored the marco news, or iron ore moves, China’s woes with imports/exports, BHP Billiton issues and other areas, merely time rationed. Its interesting to note there are subsidies for purchasing cars if you “live in a rural area.” As migrant work forces are considered as living in Rural Areas, the mainstream media may need to wake up and consider the significance of such a stimulus…bringing forward more purchases by near 3 years!

Atb Fraser

Monday 14 December 2015

Morning Mumble: Tribal (TRB) the tone continues...China, Lonmin (LMI) & Amur's Christmas Present.

Good Morning, 

Machine gun like this morning...

Tribal Group (TRB) - EMC coverage from October. The suspicions we had two months ago have proven accurate and they’ve certainly thrown the kitchen sink in…To quote:

One has a suspicion that the Chief Executive search hasn't gone as seamlessly as thought. What is the debt position of the company and more so....see bold (additions from EMC) that should be thought provoking. There are some positives, we didn't need to highlight the entire announcement. That's Tribal's third strike on the bases of profits/performance updates and as such the caveat of caution applies, expect a kitchen sink approach upon appointment. 

Its Rights Issue and Move to AIM, Tribal have now made the statement that so many before them have ignored. Standard Chartered (STAN) and Lonmin (LMI) both casualties of the same approach, waving a flag for the Rights Issue? The finances are dire…With that in mind and a whiff of smoke and fire, its time for the market to acknowledge the facts and stick the knife in. So expect averaging down, running or avoiding…

The Chinese retail sales and industrial output figures were a surprise, with the shift to consumption growing in pace, there’s time over Christmas to consider the implications for the wider markets. What the implications are for the non-performing loans, negative equity and the overall indebtedness of the Chinese commodities sector and associated industries. China’s Premier and Executives know full well the problems brewing in the mining provinces and the discontent that is brewing.

With Christmas upon us, the rally is likely to be muted as the realities of trading updates and profit warnings increase the anxiety on the visibility in earnings. Albeit, it is the week of celebration and joy, with interest rates being increased in the US on the 16th December. With that China has linked their currency to a broader basket (FT) …but are the rate hikes in the US priced in? The rate cuts and stimulus so far in China appears to be helping the economy, expect more from China post the US interest rate hike.

2016 will present a very different mix of opportunities in the markets, both in the commodities space and retail. With the FTSE hitting the 6K target for near Christmas it’s time for a reality check. Oil and Base Metals will pretty much determine the global markets over the coming weeks…and going into 2016. M&A should now be considered...essential. 

Lonmin (LMI) thank their shareholders… the shareholders are unlikely to be releasing a similar RNS to the management? With the confirmation from the Public Investment Corporation of South Africa (PIC) being stuffed with a 29.99% holding. With so many changes in the PGM space the industry still needs to shut in capacity. LMI’s efforts will assist but we estimate the sector is over supplied by near 650K ounces per annum. With the Russian Ruble weakness it’s not likely to reduce anytime soon.

With the season of goodwill upon us, we wish Crede Capital Group seasonal tidings. It would appear Crede are also in a festive mood, as AmurMinerals announced today.

Atb Fraser

Monday 7 December 2015

Morning Mumble: Hiatuses and...Ken's Mare (KMR) Equity for shareholders? Anglo + De Beers, Glencore and some news about a former Jam Tomorrow Employee Rurelec & Questions for their NOMAD.

Good Morning,

Very busy - although amusingly, there were suggestions we had visited the dark side and started working for a long-only fund! Chance for a recap later this week on the pertinent issues from the 22 November to present, although nothing much has changed, save for news driven events.

Iluka Resources sensibly announced the long-awaited termination of discussions with Kenmare Resources (KMR) - it’s wise for parties to read the RNS. Those followers will be unsurprised by this "news.” 

KMR equity holders have the opportunity to participate in the dreams of the future. So to sugar-coat the dire state of the KMR’s financial position they have announced plans for an investment by State General Reserve Fund (SGRF), a further capital raising, and balance sheet restructuring

Over to KMR (bold, italics and underlining are additions):-

SGRF, a sovereign wealth fund of the Sultanate of Oman, has approved in principle an investment of US$100 million in the firm placing via one of its subsidiaries, subject to and conditional upon, inter alia, agreement of a subscription agreement, agreement of arrangements with the Group's project lenders on the Group's capital structure, procurement of commitments from other shareholders in respect of an additional minimum US$75 million capital, necessary Kenmare shareholder approvals, and finalisation of a prospectus.

Wait….continue reading:

Moma is a world-class asset that encompasses a large, long life ore body. Total invested capital exceeds US$1.2 billion, with the mine producing more than 7% of global TiO2 feedstock supply - being the largest merchant producer of ilmenite globally.

Having invested capital that exceeds $1.2B, and producing 7% of global TiO2 feedstock, it would appear the management are going to hang around to run the next stage of the "KMR turnaround story/saga." This is despite being in charge whilst a transformation of a once multi-million pound company into a small cap with a £12M valuation took place. One has to wonder what the board’s remuneration and bonuses have been over the years in comparison to the returns for shareholders. 

The question that those supporting shareholders should ask is, “are the management right for the future?” If the past is an indicator of the future, prudence would be to have a fresh start with a clean sweep. Those whom played the KMR pub quiz last year on FTML, will no doubt be aware of the dire performance for shareholders.

What’s another $175M in the grand scheme of things? Will the prudential be putting up any ‘wonga’ into the fundraiser? More to the point, is $175M enough?

There remain a number of material matters that need to be agreed to enable Kenmare to deliver the planned capital raising and there can be no certainty at this time that they will be achieved. Kenmare welcomes the indicated support from SGRF and appreciates the support of key shareholders.

We’ll watch from a distance, although if one was short, prudence would suggest closing on the news today. KMR Net Debt must be around $315-332M by EMC estimates.

Continuing with a theme of shareholder value and with some amusement for those following the debacle at LGO Energy. Judging by the latest announcement they’re off to find and/or recognise shareholder value with  a strategic review. 

LGO also update the market on the Trinity Exploration no-deal on the Tabaquite Block by issuing 41,487,776 to Trinity Exploration. Trinity’s statement on Tabaquite Block, Trinidad ends with: 

The decision to cancel the SPA has been considered as part of management's overall assessment of means to better realise the value and future potential of the Tabaquite Block. 
  
We have Glencore (GLEN) updating the market this Thursday. NH and David Sheppard at the FT ran with something a bit more positive, “Glencoreexpects to cut debt ahead of schedule.” - Sensible and common-sense discussion about GLEN's earnings forecasts in the current environment. Pay attention to the terminology used on Thursday, one suspects there may be a few statements coming from the back foot.

Sadly for GLEN's workers Collinsville coal mine in north Queensland, 180 workers are to lose their jobs. Is this an admission of the dire state of the coal industry? It certainly explains why Mick Davis is taking his time with X2 Resources, perhaps to Rio's annoyance. 

In the weekend press we had Anglo American allegedly slashing their dividend (again and again), talk about echoes – news must be thin on the ground! Anglo’s investors’ day tomorrow (08th Dec). We can no doubt look forward to all the positives of a diversified miner and what this offers investors, whilst struggling with depressed pricing.

With Anglo’s subsidiaries either under water in terms of operational costs (Kumba Iron Ore/De Beers), lacking flexibility in CAPEX (Minas Rio) or needing to deleverage the balance sheet. The future doesn't look rosy. Anglo is now realising the hard choices it has to make and the limited flexibility. Quite why they have not pressed the equity raise/capital injection button is anyone’s guess. Surely they'll want to get in there before all the others?

We note that De Beers have sold Kimberley Mines in South Africa to Petra Diamonds and Ekapa Mining for a rather low sum. If one looks at the capital De Beers spent on Kimberly and the plant etc…it gives a rather good indication of the amount pressure to monetise what assets they have/can sell.  An article from May 2015, makes for an interesting read… Engineering News - De Beers inviting bids for life-extending takeover of Kimberley Mines. Was the USD to South African Rand/ZAR near $1:ZAR5 in 2002/3?

For those that have followed a company Rurelec that we consider jam tomorrow, its not often one gets validated in their views so quickly. Over the weekend attention was drawn to the following announcement on Independent Power Corporation PLC.  See the previous commentary here (EMC) when the IPC was "spun out" or Rurelec to allegedly save costs.

Questions:
a)      When did the Independent Power Corporation PLC, Peter Earl and Anglo Kazakh TransAsian Pipeline Corporation Limited commence discussions? We may be able to update on this shortly...
b)      Was this before or after the spin off?
c)       Was the NOMAD consulted on the “spin-off?”

See the original announcement and terminology 19th June 2015 - Director Change (Peter Earl) leaving & IPC. Then see the replacement, Spinout of Subsidiary. Albeit it’s somewhat immaterial as the horse has already bolted.

Atb Fraser.