Showing posts with label Shandong. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shandong. Show all posts

Thursday, 8 October 2015

Morning Mumble: Chinese Auto's (Designs) - reduction in sales tax + housing stimulus + Vedanta (Iron ore), Glencore (Thermal Coal + PGM) and Centamin

Good Morning, 

Near all mining/resource stocks rose until the last hour yesterday where profit-taking took place. In part due to the Chinese machine waking up in what would have been near 12hrs later.  With one day of trading before a weekend, the markets will be looking to some indication of the Chinese outlook. In addition of course to the PR (Glencore) and the overall commodity price actions. The SHCOMP finished up near 3% in thin but positive trading.

With shorting currently limited in China it’s unlikely anyone has been impacted significantly and in fact, their market is likely to have profited. There will be a read across to the higher material costs to Chinese manufacturers and producers. Despite thin volume, iron ore has been slipping and with margin requirements being higher, don’t expect too much of a recovery with supply increasing.

We've discussed the decline in liquidity in China for some time, whether in SOE's (State Owned Enterprises), private sector or Local Government, there’s a very consistent theme. The FT has highlighted what has been known about for some time: China futures market decimated by trading curbs. All the same worth a read, but more so to keep an eye how things pan out. 

News is apparently flowing out of China that new stimulus packages were announced whilst the Golden Week Holidays were in full flow. It wasn’t this week at all, the policy came into effect on the 1st October, just in time for the Golden Week! One wonders when people will read the press releases properly.

In an effort to stop the rot and improve the decline in car sales (See: CAAM Chinese Association of Automobile Manufacturers), they have cut the sales tax on passenger vehicles to 5% (from 10%). The criteria is limited to engines below the 1,600CC and time limited until the end Dec 2016. 

With a degree of humour, VW might have some good news - China are likely to implement additional incentives for cars that don’t meet the emission standards. We obviously avoided calling the scheme scrappage.

For Western Manufacturers importing or operating under a JV there will be some positives. The main beneficiaries are likely to be the Chinese manufacturers with small engines. Feel free to check out the designs see: Great Wall Automobile Company, Guangzhou Automobile Group Co., Ltd (GAC), Zhejiang Geely Holding Group, Changan and SAIC Autos (MG Rover etc...). We are obviously not qualified to comment on the design or quality, perhaps there’s some cultural differences one needs to acknowledge?

Considering the last time (2008/09) such a specific stimulus was implemented, sales peaked near 40%, albeit declined 50% year on year until now being reduced back to normalised single-digit growth.

With consumption being the key focus, a mobile population will be incentivised to spend hard. Whether it be an increased numbers of shopping trips, holidays (driving holidays are on the increase), eating or visiting family, it’s a delightable feast for the economy and the tax revenues!  Assuming of course that the Chinese buy into the enticement / tax cut.

With income growth slowing, deflation and risk of redundancy or job sharing in most sectors, being enticed to take on the liability of a car with a) via credit or b) utilise savings – it’s going to be hard to entice new customers.

Until more recently similar contractions have been seen in the housing sector, where buyers have been unwilling to buy in significant numbers. What with the newly married “living” with parents situation is on the increase again in China.

Property buyers in China know all too well about paying over the odds for assets. Last week’s adjustment to the down payment requirements for a home will aid the property sector. With a reduction to 25% from 30% it’s a notable enticement for some. Although only likely to benefit those whom are well on the road to purchasing a property – albeit purchasing off the Government is still the preferred method with such hefty discounts available.

China now has an emerging tier 1 and 2 divide (North-South Divide), where prices of property in small cities and towns are falling, whilst larger towns are seeing a renewed interest. Aided in part by a reduction in prices, free-goods and price reductions that the tier 1 market has barely had to adopt to motivate sales. (See Top 10 below – if you have to buy)
  1. Hong Kong
  2. Shanghai
  3. Beijing
  4. Shenzhen
  5. Guangzhou
  6. Shenyang
  7. Qingdao
  8. Nanjing
  9. Tianjin- this may however change as investment is focused elsewhere. 
  10. Chengdu

We had Vedanta seeking permission to export more iron ore from Goa. Why they’re bothering with prices at $40/t FOB, is anyone’s guess with Roy Hill and Tonkolili (Shandong) firing up. One suspects they have to be at full capacity to make their operations modestly cashflow positive.

Just as Glencore’s had plugged most of the holes, yet more market woes. NH@FT’s article on Australia thermal coal price at 8-year low has been followed by Coal Problems Being Made Worse by Global Slowdown, Glencore Says (BBerg) - not the best timing for Glencore. However, one is minded to think conservatively with regard to thermal coal.

Its best to avoid sticking pins to prices specifically, especially the likes of coal where so many have been burnt before. It’s prudent to test the theory that the prices are perhaps near to the bottom - over to X2 Resources and Rio.

Like many in the commodities space, the marginal producers have been saved by costs that are reflected in dollar terms, with a benefit from a weak local currency for labour and energy/fuel costs reducers. The operators have averted (delayed) the inevitable pressures to shut in production/mothball. As the situation reverses, expect a tightening in supply to benefit pricing.

Glencore’s discounted offering is as a result of declining demand in once upon a time more stable markets that had some degree of clarity in outlook. Japan’s restart of Nuclearreactors  benefited the likes of Tohoku Electric Power, whom have just agreed with Glencore for premium thermal coal contract at $64.60/t.  A near 14% discount to the previous contract has not gone unnoticed.

The issues being experienced in South Korea and Taiwan won’t have helped the bargaining power of the thermal coal producers. Asian countries, with a majority of trade bias towards China are starting to see a tightening of liquidity in part because of reduced trade with China.

As a positive Oil, save for any major uplift in crude supply (Shale operators be warned) that would impact on pricing, its likely to have found some form of a floor. With shale producers having an appetite to hedge their production around current prices, its suggesting production is reaching some form of normality - contrary to the earlier opportunities that were missed.

Glencore appear to not be pushing the news they’ve shut in production at the Eland platinum mine in South Africa, with the loss of 818 jobs.

Over to gold - Centamin Egypt (CEY) Q32015 Preliminary Production Results reminding the market why it’s sensible to factor in lower on grades, production or machinery woes. CEY’s grades weren’t near the reserve average, so suspect costs to be impacted to a small degree.

Given a sensible headwind in grades, CEY are likely to just drag themselves over the 430K bottom line guidance by near 2K ounces, assuming production of near 110K+ ounces in the 4th Quarter. A reminder that production was meant to have annualised at a rate of 450K ounces by the 3rd Quarter if not the 4th. As stated in the Q1 production results. Date for diary, 11th November 2015.

Finally, a positive result for Northern Dynasty Minerals, where a report by Former US Senator & Secretary of Defense William S. Cohen has been released. Suffice to say it doesn’t read well for the conduct of the EPA.   

Atb Fraser

Tuesday, 29 September 2015

Pm Bolt-On: A belated Wolseley (WOS) with a soapbox item & Glencore's open secret - lines of credit or nooses of liquidity + Have Roy Hill & Tonkolili gone short iron ore!? Come on KAZ get with it...

Good Morning,

It was hoped that this week would allow a bit more time. 

With all the indicators suggesting some form of doom, why is Gold not up? Liquidity is contracting, outlooks are being adjusted, China's liquidity issues for SOE's are coming out, including their need to export deflation and recession to other countries. 

Wolseley's (WOS) final results weren't all that, with a feeling here that WOS were calling the top of the market. The plumb centre owner reiterated exactly what the market knew. The savages took their profits and retreated to the caves. WOS, a viable company, but the outlook isn't that great. 

Over to WOS with additions from the EMC in bold to highlight the short:

Ian Meakins, Chief Executive, commented:

"The highlight of these results was another great performance by Ferguson in the US where we achieved strong like-for-like revenue growth ahead of the market and a 50 basis point improvement in the trading margin to 8.2%, which is a record.  We continue to face some challenging markets in the rest of the Group and remain focused on improving growth rates and protecting gross margins whilst keeping the cost base tight. 

"Wolseley continues to be highly cash generative and we have adequate resources to fund our capital investment programme, bolt-on acquisitions and growth in ordinary dividends. We are also announcing a £300 million share buyback which reflects the Group's strong financial position and management's confidence in the business."

Commenting on the outlook, Ian Meakins said:

"We expect to generate like-for-like revenue growth of about 4 per cent in the first half.  In the US we expect continued good growth in Blended Branches, Waterworks, HVAC, B2C and Fire and Fabrication underpinned by decent Commercial and Residential markets. However, Industrial markets in North America, which account for about 15 per cent of revenue in the region, were challenging in the fourth quarter and we expect this to continue.  We expect a continued steady recovery in Nordic markets, although the heating market in the UK is expected to remain very competitive with little growth.  Overall, we expect to make continued progress in 2016."

The buyback may offer some support, but is this the best Wolseley can do with £300M? With net debt at circa £805M, prudence would dictate either an acquisition or reducing debt. Then again...with a fall in full-year profits one has to prop up ones share price. 

The concern here is that companies should be focused on the strength of the business not the ability to leverage to show strength. China have met with similar issues in recent times and company buybacks are simply a waste (view here). We're fully aware of the pros and cons, but in the absence of a viable strategy of investment, take it as a signal that irrespective of outlooks, the management are waving a flag of..."this is the best we can do." 

The writedowns are showing the fragility of the market place across all sectors. WOS's guidance on the Nordic business with writedowns and the outlook for the US business should not be ignored. The outlook contradicts the logical buyback principles. The expansion and acquisition of decent companies would surely be a sensible alternative to enhancing longer-term value. 

It’s acknowledged Wolseley acquired, but buybacks do not improve a business performance, only the earnings relating to each share. This is not always the best measurement, as the EMC has evidenced many times before…

With the FED considering interest rate rises and the alleged strength in the US, the guidance given contradicts some bulls. Reiterated by WOS statement of price deflation in the USA, UK and Central Europe and modest price inflation in Canada and the Nordic.

Glencore have come out with a statement in response to speculation (PDF/in full below). 

Baar, Switzerland 29 September, 2015 

Response to speculation 

Glencore has taken proactive steps to position our company to withstand current commodity market conditions. 

Our business remains operationally and financially robust – we have positive cash flow, good liquidity and absolutely no solvency issues. 

We are getting on and delivering a suite of measures to reduce our debt levels by up to US$10.2 billion. 

Glencore has no debt covenants and continues to retain strong lines of credit and secure access to funding thanks to long term relationships we have with the banks. 

We remain focused on running efficient, low cost and safe operations and are confident the medium and long-term fundamentals of the commodities we produce and market remain strong into the future. (Ends)

So in essence, Glencore have so far had a placing they allegedly did not need to conduct but did to assure investors. Now they're robust and operationally/financially sound. Whatever have Capt. Kirk and Scotty got planned next. 

Well, we're sure that's all fine and dandy. The gossip/rumours suggest all is not as rosy at the mill. Cargill's winding down of their $7bn hedge fund arm (FT) won't have assisted Glencore in the sale of the grains business.

With the current outlook and Russian taxation woes that are likely to have hurt GLEN, the suggested price tag of $12B for the grains business may be a struggle. Then again they got significantly more for the Las Bambas mine in Peru - over to the sales folk. 

There's gossip suggesting that Glencore are having issues with suppliers. This is unsubstantiated at the moment, but with credit lines and liquidity tightening globally, it’s with no surprise that rumours are surfacing of a big utility company cutting its credit line to GLEN. If this is true, what are the implications for operations? It will undoubtedly have operational and financial implications. 

One is wise to measure Glencore on its assets, the price of its commodities and marketing, in conjunction with its debt. Simply, the assets, save for coal are tier 2 (EMC view) without significant investment (see African Copper Update) to improve operational performance, and until the development of these assets the outlook will remain challenging. 

With some large IB's and analysts believing that Glencore is a viable business, this won't on its own make for a lower risk investment case and suggests an element of knife catching. Certain Brokerages have advocated that there are participants willing to lend to Glencore in comparison to than Anglo American (AAL). This in its own right isn't necessarily the best comparison, albeit, it does indicate what some brokers/analysts are using as a comparator. The absence of comparatives to tier one commodities companies rather says a lot.


Would it pay to buy Glencore? Quite frankly the unknown operational model poses some risks, but it’s always nice to have some higher risk exposure. It’s noted that personally the risks of being long are greater than having been negative on Glencore since IPO. This doesn't mean there cannot be a share price recovery, with the machine doing the rounds, expect some support. Investors would be wise to keep an eye on commodity prices.

To end on a cheery note, another leveraged play on commodities Freeport-McMoRan (NYSE: FCX). FCX had some good news with the drill head. Their 100% owned Horn Mountain Deep well in the Gulf of Mexico came in on the money The release in any other market would have been positive, more so, if it didn't mean the commitment of $$ to enable production the share price would have perhaps risen. Over to Icahn to break this one up…

Thought for the week - Rio/BHP plus Fortescue Metals Group (FMG), when's the impact of Roy Hill going to bring down the axe on iron ore? Inventories normalising again in China, and so a reducing demand globally. Its noted, Shandong Iron and Steel Group's are now back in production at Tonkolili. Those whom love romance in the market place will remember Tonkolili used to be owned by African Minerals (AMI).

One hopes that the acquisition of the Tonkolili Mine by Shandong was above board. It never rains but it poors (poor I know) for the former-AMI.  AWOKO article - one hopes the 'new' AMI has resolved such minor issues as moisture content, shipping and diesel disappearing. What are the chances of a three-pronged stimulus by China just as ore hits the market? 

Have KAZ Minerals got their cap out yet?!?! Put us out of our misery on the 50 pence rights issue please?!?!

Atb Fraser

Over to the grammar police/time limited and long-days.