Morning Mumble: BHP's South32 (Short32) allegedly less debt & BLT favours, yeah right! Rio's SP10 *(No Sun-protection) and ANTO.

Good Morning, 

There appears to be a lot of misinformation surrounding South32 in the press, where the journos need to take their socks off. There's no way in the world BLT could have loaded Short32 with any more debt, without significant risk to its debt rating and/or higher borrowing costs. Worse, the press have ignored the level at which BLT would have created a defaulting structure that would breach the legal requirements of corporate governance. 

The press ignore the fact that BLT have to ensure that South32/Short32 must be able to operate as a going concern. The commentators prefer to 'believe' that BLT are doing Short32 a favour by reducing the debt. When the sums of the liabilities are put to a total, they are in fact higher, merely labelled differently. 

For those not wishing to split-hairs, the liabilities are higher than 'consensus' with rehabilitation and closure ($1.5B and that may be circa 15-17% on the low side) plus debt of $674M, taking the liabilities and debt to $2.174B, with a $1.5b revolving credit facility being made available. When one considers the on-going liabilities, excluding those clearly labelled debt, its going to make leveraging (without dilution/equity raise) for any acquisitions very difficult, irrespective of the alleged financial prudence attached. Let’s see how the dividend policy goes. 

BLT define South32, as having high quality metals that will be a cash generator, that allegedly the "larger investors" welcome. We'll ignore the volatility of the entire asset class, with a cursory prompt for readers to check the price movements of aluminium recently, manganese is under pressure and coal is not without its significant woes; not so enticing when put in context. Of course Short32's dividend policy will entice the low risk miss-believers into acquiring the stock. 

 

With Manganese, Silver, Lead, Zinc and Alumina making up near 38.6% of Short32’s EBITDA, Short32 may benefit from the Bauxite supply issues thanks to Indonesia's unprocessed ore ban, and declining stocks of Aluminium/Bauxite and Alumina, but how have silver, lead and zinc performed? With any further slowdown in China, don't expect too much in the way of price appreciation, more so a levelling out of both Nickel and Aluminium.  

Staying with mining, and an indicator of the state of the market, Rio yesterday put a tender out for a cargo of high alumina SP10 iron ore cargo. Suffice to say this cargo has had limited interest. The Chinese simply are not prepared to take it without a huge discount, in fact, many aren't/weren't prepared to accept it. 

Higher alumina (circa 3.5%+) content in iron ore causes the slag to become 'rather' fluid during the steel-making process. Processors can be blend the higher grades with lower grade. Simply put, pollution/environmental regulations restrict these deals and limit the price. 5 years ago, some savvy traders would have combined the deal with some low alumina ore from Vale, blended it and made a profit. In today’s commodity cycle, it’s simply not worth the effort or time for most, without a decent discount circa 10%+

Antofagasta (ANTO) have surprised the market with worse than expected preliminary results (2014). We'll save the readers from obtaining an accountancy degree and wade through the waffle in machine gun like fashion. Copper prices down near 14%+ on the corresponding period, taxation in Chile up (it’s only been in force since 1st October 2014/PWC did a very good peace around this time). With margins under pressure and desalination likely to increase costs per pound, what were the markets hoping for today? Simply put, if the investors haven't already priced in lower expectation, they should be from now one in, but all is not lost! 

ANTO's Los Pelambres issues will have an impact on the next set of accounts. With a trending reduction in oil/energy costs, ANTO only managed a cash costs before by-product credits at $1.83/lb, a modest were 2.2% higher than the previous year despite a decline peso. These costs will grow as the wage deals / salary increases kick in over the next 4 years and the declines post reporting period in the copper price.

On a positive, any weakness in the Peso will benefit the reporting cash costs and CAPEX/OPEX expenditure with net cash costs, including by-product credits being a healthy $1.43/lb. The potential upside from Antucoya, Encuentro Oxides and Centinela should not be ignored.  One might just start to turn positive on ANTO with its cash costs being an envy, save for any more radicalisation and issues at Los Pelambres (and the El Mauro tailings dam). The reoccurring theme of grades should not be ignored though but better than management guidance, nor for every 1% movement in the PESO (CLP), it equates to $0.0075 cents P+ve/N-ve to production costs at the current USD Vs.CLP (Chilean Peso).

Unnecessary cheer at Lonmin (LMI) with the appointment of COO Ben Moolman and Bowleven (BLVN) finally have the cash in the bank. The market "may" just re-rate the company, albeit past performance and sector/industry woes will hinder any blue skies beliefs. Juridica Investments (JIL) disappointing the market for no particular reason with their final results. A long-term hold with some very good dividends so far, illiquid so one for the traders as well!

Atb Fraser

Morning Mumble: All that Glitters Au Ag, Amara's placing, Weatherly, GLIF & JD Wetherspoon.

Good Morning, 

A pleasure when the smaller boys make a decent packet out of the market in comparison to the houses of grandeur such as the high fees for M&A or the odd take private element. 

Having traded long on gold on the back of CHF and China, yes China gave gold a leg up plus Asian trading and NY. China's data created yet more demand on gold risk, so this morning its time to take the majority of profits (perhaps earlier buy but yet again solid profits). It’s not so long ago a few savvy investors picked up some significant low cost gold bets (EMC). It would appear the corporate gold traders were caught napping by the move and very few have profited from the appreciation of gold. Kudos to the few, with a not so paltry pay cheque either.

With gold and silver in fashion at the moment, it is wise to buy exposure into those leveraged plays such as the once upon a time short, HOC (Hochschild) who has appreciated near 30% since the change in sentiment and trend for Ag circa $18.30/oz. HOC's now making a profit again! With HOC's Q4 production update being a lot better than most (includingmyself thought). 

The HOC holders can breathe a sigh of relief with HOC completing a decent hedging programme to lock in some transparency over cashflow even if prices appreciate. With HOC signing agreements to hedge the sale of 6,000,000 ounces of silver at $17.75 per ounce for 2015. This is in addition to the previous agreement to hedge 38,000 ounces of gold for 2015 at $1,300 per ounce.

We'll side step Petropavlovsk (POG) purely on the basis of unnecessary appreciation over Christmas and without justification. 

Copper appears to be looking for a floor / support in the price at the moment, although the deals being done and stocks increasing at LME certainly leave a lot for the interpretation. The guessing for copper will continue as two dominant warrant holders sit on their hands (maybe slightly singed). 

With metal warranted against the January 2015 date becoming prompt this week supplies are likely to up-tick contradicting the narrow bands of supply and demand. One certainly to keep your eye on if trading, especially if the physical market becomes tighter (allegedly) again. (Circa 19th April 2015). One suspects that Standard Bank's Aug/Sept notes on copper might need a slight revision. 

The question over the short-term is will the Chinese smelter excess still be managed appropriately (drip feeding back in to the market) with some losses stacking up or is there likely to be a very short-term swell in physical to meet obligations? The market I suspect will wait till factory restarts before taking an opinion. With factory gate prices lower there's pressure on the market to maintain a competitive (read as cheaper) attractiveness.

We see the results of Amara Mining's (AMA) placing which shaves certain assumptions off the target or take out price, down around 10% of previous estimates (Approximate 25.2 - 28 pence now.) The positives are any suitor is wise to acknowledge AMA is now far from vulnerable to speculative approaches being funded to an investment project decision and is supported. If the book-build was so well supported why is there a discount to market of 15% or thereabouts? 

In-between AMA's announcement of its intentionto conduct a placing (worth a read) and today the costs of the BFS and completion apparently appreciated 10% or should it be the needs appreciated 10%. It’s acknowledged that with a prevailing wind for gold it was wise to press the button on cash. The disappointment being, if Peel Hunt and GMP Securities Europe had to offer a discount on the price, it does not bode well for other entities looking for cash. So in the absence of Randgold (EMC May 2014) news or Samsung, Q4 2015 looks to be the date in mind, one hopes financing can be encouraged in the current gold climate sooner rather than later. 

Stating the obvious award goes to J D Wetherspoon(JDW) with increased competition from the supermarkets. JDW more recent declines I thought were obvious, with landlords’ holidays often taken post-Christmas? With calls for equality in treatment stating the obvious bad news in the sector etc...if JDW don't like the sector why are they operating in it? Expanding yet claiming discriminatory pressures is never a good thing with increased LFL sales and margins, albeit under pressure from their wage increases are healthy. JDW's update will be taken as well as Majestic Wine's (MJW)! The hangover should have been taken post-Christmas. 

Its the day for the GLIF  (GLI Finance ) dividend announcement (see: EMC GLIF April 2014) and only two days ago Inspired Capital (INSC) (the old Renovo aka Ultimate Finance Group) trading update.

Bowleven (BLVN) informed the market of the two well exploration drilling programme on the Bomono Permit, with fingers cross for the company (no position), they'll need it! WTI (Weatherly International) quarterly operations and production update does not bode well! From EMC, will it stop the rot!, we had our answer sooner than expected! 

Little time to discuss the BLT (BHP Billiton) Operational Review Half Year Ended 31 Dec 2014 shale being an obvious candidate for some tighter cost controls and copper even performing well (grades?), Anglo Pacific's update on the Kestrel royalty, seeming like desperation to maintain the SP. Afren's update hasn't gone down well re: amortisation payment.

Atb Fraser

Evening Bolt On: Food Glorious Food

Hopefully tomorrow the glut in cheap food and their surpluses...Feed Grains, Soya and Milk (Chinese over supply limited demand). This depends on a number of factors but may have to be put back to another day (read as never judging by past performance). There's likely to be some global intolerance both for gluten and lactose (poor I know). 

Oil's bounced with par trading between Brent and WTI, the game of chess is afoot. One would be wise to consider longs as higher risk but with significant reward if one catches the knife correctly. Significant interest in 2015 December Brent Futures circa $57.20/bbl. Floating storage? Oil to Asia, components and exports to America and Europe whilst the routes are cheap.

Today it was rude not to sell Bowleven (BLVN) and Greggs (GRG), whether this over time proves right, its something that I don't look over my shoulder at but will review. Having ridden the wave and made an paltry profit on the long BLVN trades I have little patience for it in the current climate. Greggs's only justification is on the news...

We should spend a moment in silence for those copper traders in denials about the price with limited time left before their positions need a resolution! A key price was hit today.

Very long day, Atb Fraser